Maritime training in the digital era – beware of cross track error
“Cross Track Error (XTE) is the distance that vessel is off the course either to port or starboard. It is usually caused by drift due to environmental factors. Those involved in maritime operation will understand how important it is to be aware of XTE, as it is at the core of corrective action.”
The maritime industry is experiencing a paradigm shift while operating in an everchanging environment influenced by digitalisation and decarbonisation. Technological developments, particularly new digital technologies and Industry 4.0, are rapidly reshaping the maritime industry. As the industry responds to this shift, are we experiencing a XTE in our approach to maritime education and training?
Academic drift describes the process whereby knowledge that has been useful gradually loses close ties to practice by becoming more tightly integrated with a body of scientific knowledge. Monitoring academic drift is critical to ensuring the skills of maritime professionals are aligned to the changing needs of the industry. Maritime Education and Training (MET) must evolve to provide training, and retraining, that is relevant to practice.
A changing global maritime landscape
The ongoing pandemic has highlighted the indispensable role that the maritime industry plays in the global economy. Seafarers are at the heart of shipping and are the critical element in operating today’s modern and technologically sophisticated ships safely and efficiently. Maritime shipping operates in a complex eco-socio-technical environment, with stringent international regulations that react to economic, political, and socially variable conditions.
Safety of navigation services provided by authorities are becoming more digital and complex in their nature. New skills are needed both to consume and to provide such services, which may include highly automated and intelligent aids to navigation and vessel traffic services.
Maritime transport has been identified as a laggard sector in the Industry Digitalisation Index. Recent regulatory and sustainability demands have provided the momentum to fully embrace digital transformation.
Within the constructs of global trade, the interactions of producers, manufacturers and consumers are in flux, and consequently, the expectations of maritime shipping are changing. However, the traditional structured and measured approach of implementing technologies is no longer able to keep pace with the rate of change.
This change creates a need for new skills and competencies for maritime professionals – both afloat and ashore. Shipping requires a quality, motivated and appropriately skilled labour force to thrive, and therefore, requires revision and alignment of the education and training of seafarers to meet the changing requirements. MET must provide appropriate knowledge and expertise to create a ‘future ready’ maritime workforce to meet the needs of a diverse range of stakeholders (as illustrated below).
The emerging global maritime landscape is characterised by an enhanced degree of interaction and synchronisation among the multiple players engaged in the self-organised ecosystem of maritime transports. The performance of port community systems largely depends on the capacity, collaboration, and participation of the port community members and on the collaboration of the carriers.
Evolving concepts in maritime education
Augmented reality, artificial intelligence, autonomous operations, and big data are becoming part of maritime operations. Traditionally, MET institutes cater to the requirements of the International Convention on Standards of Training, Certification and Watchkeeping for Seafarers (STCW) regulations, when developing curricula of training focusing on the delivery of IMO Model Courses.
The STCW Convention and Code (as amended) sets out the current international benchmark for the training and education of seafarers. The 2010 Manila amendments to the STCW Convention and Code marked a major revision of the STCW Convention and Code. These amendments were aimed at bringing the Convention and Code up to date with recent and foreseeable developments.
However, the pace of operational and technological advances in the maritime operations in recent years continues to accelerate. This means ships, ports and logistics hubs have become sophisticated sensor hubs and data generators.
The ship and shore now digitally interact real time. While compliance with STCW standards is essential, the industry’s diverse stakeholders need maritime education and training that aligns with ongoing technological changes and raise the industry’s capital productivity.
Changing technology and customer expectations requires an MET course correction. Traditional curriculum design influenced by technological integration needs to reflect, and be inspired by, the ongoing innovation in the industry.
The use of simulators in maritime education and training, for instance, has been an essential component for developing seafarer’s skills and competencies for decades. Emerging immersive technologies, such as virtual reality (VR) and augmented reality (AR) create new and exciting possibilities for maritime training.
Digitalisation and automation are transforming the shipping sector. Ships, ports and maritime logistics are increasingly data enabled and need a work force that can use data analytics to turn data streams into information for enhanced decision making. Employees, at all levels, need new competencies to effectively manage a digitally enabled sustainable transport system.
Skills of the future
The theme of maritime informatics is uniting practitioners and academics to jointly contribute towards upgrading the human capital required by an increasingly digital industry. Environmental and technological changes demand a series of perspective transitions to training, as outlined below.
Learning Strategy – From ‘Fragmented learning’ to ‘Learn to learn’
- You have to be on watch to learn how to be on watch.
- Training only works in a classroom or during a sea phase.
- Every new piece of equipment needs to have a training programme.
In the future
- Focus on learning to learn, rather than learning to know or do; focus on continuous learning, rather than standalone programmes. With so many new ‘bits of kit’ coming out, we can’t be spending time training on each new tool – we need to learn how to learn, know how to decide what we need to know.
Learning Perspective – From ‘Imitative learning’ to ‘Continuous learning’
- I learned it, so they need to also (the crushing cadet syndrome – when I was a cadet I had to… so you need to too).
- I need to teach what I know, so they know it too (comfort zone – I know this, it was good for me, you need to know this too – doesn’t matter if it is for something that doesn’t exist or not used anymore…).
In the future
- Recognise that the industry is continuously changing at an accelerating rate. We need to provide skills for the future, not the past.
Evolving roles – From ‘Back to Basics’ to ‘Basics of the future’
- What happens when technology fails? You have to know the old ways! Nothing like looking out the window, mark-one eyeball.
- Need to keep up the basics – like using paper charts, set and drift, Astro, manual calculation for UKC/ADC, sketch and describe engines.
In the future
- We need to focus on the outcome of using new ‘tools’ – using the tools for safe navigation and efficient propulsion.
- Focus training on the tools in use now, not the tools that were.
- Change the ‘basics’ by increasing the ability to adapt to changing systems without losing relationships with existing technologies.
Battle of the Ss – From ‘Exclusion’ to ‘Inclusion’
- Ship is better than Shore … no, Shore is better than Ship …
- Ship: Why is the shore interfering? They live in that ivory tower and don’t understand the ‘real world’.
- Shore: What are they trying to do on the Ship? They don’t understand the limitations of the equipment.
In the future
- Collaboration, information sharing, making use of digital data to support vessel resource management (VRM), port resource management (PRM), and beyond. Working to ensure physical and psychologically safe working environments.
- Understand your role in global supply chain, there are no shore operations without the ship, and ship operations need to work with shore.
Digesting Data – From ‘Data ingestion’ to ‘Data analytics’
- My role is operational. Data is not for me.
- Data analytics isn’t required for my role – I’m a mate, an engineer, a rating, a wharf worker.
- Data is for the office boffins, the bean counters – not for those doing the ‘real’ work.
In the future
- Understand the role of data in improving decision making. Identify and develop skills not only as data providers but also as data consumers.
- Utilise data analytics to enhance operational and capital efficiency.
- Understand the data being generated, its use, what to trust and the relevance of data to the need for information.
Education in transition
A significant percentage of the world’s seafarers come from the developing economies. Due to the lack of institutional infrastructure and capacity, MET institutions in these economies struggle to meet even existing standards. Therefore, it is imperative to address this lack of capability along with ensuring that knowledge transfers are nurtured through multilateral relationships that cross the digital divide.
There are opportunities to develop cooperative endeavours, making effective use of tools and technology to close the existing gap. It is time to facilitate a truly global digital revolution in the maritime sector to build a maritime workforce that has the skill sets to embrace the range of environmental, social, and technological developments.
The world’s maritime educational institutions need to respond to the current eco-socio-technical disruptions by producing relevant, industry ready graduates with ‘future ready’ skill sets. The training must evolve to be cognisant of the impacts of the 4th revolution on the maritime industry and the role of MET in enabling the adoption and implementation of relevant technology and addressing new expectations. Harnessing these capabilities is critical to deliver digitalised and decarbonised future ready ships and ports.
Revolutions are an abrupt change in past practices, and we assert that the maritime sector’s future will be determined by its willingness to redirect the course of established MET patterns to get on track for a productive future.
Editor’s note: This is an edited version of the original article, which contains a full list of references and is downloadable here.